Sep 09 2015

What art can teach us about knowledge work

painting4How Art Reveals the Limits of Neuroscience” by Alva Noë is a fascinating read that asks us to step beyond the idea that we are our brains. It is stimulating me to reflect on some things I’ve been trying to articulate about knowledge sharing and  the transformation knowledge into new ideas, application, etc. It relates to some conversations on how we share knowledge across research projects, between journalists who care about their communities, and people who are trying to improve the world.

In observing how our experience of art changes when someone else shares their experience of the work, Noë writes:

This shift — from not seeing to seeing, from seeing to seeing differently, from not getting it to getting it — is actually very common. We live and learn, look and ask, bring what’s around us into focus continuously. At least part of what makes art different, or special, is that it yields the opportunity not only to “get” something, perhaps something new, but also to catch ourselves in the very act. In this way, art illuminates us to ourselves.

Interestingly, when I started to read it, I was not actually looking at art itself. The experience Noë writes about resonated deeply to my experiences of seeing people take in an idea and transform it into something they can use, apply, and “own” in the very productive sense. Own it in terms of being able to to use it meaningfully. Imagine a way of reducing open defecation, or changing water use habits. Imagine being able to take the building blocks of an idea and transform it into a locally useful solution. She frames it as the “world as the playing field for our activity,” and thus the interplay with it.

“This is not to deny that the world acts on us, triggering events in the nervous system. Of course it does! But the thing is, we act right back. Every movement of the eye, head, and body changes the character of our sensory coupling to the world around us. Objects are not triggers for internal events in the nervous system; they are opportunities or affordances for our continuing transactions with them. The world shows up, in experience, not like a diagram in a brain chart but as the playing field for our activity. Not the brain’s activity. Our activity. Not activity inside our head. But activity in the world around us.”

Now that I’ve read it, I’m thinking about how art can help me address my challenges with knowledge work!! Take a few minutes to read the article.

3 responses so far

3 Responses to “What art can teach us about knowledge work”

  1. Scott Johnsonon 09 Sep 2015 at 8:49 pm

    Not sure if this helps? I find art teaches me I can imagine things I can’t physically reproduce. No matter how skilled I become or how hard I work at it, the drawing, painting, whatever the medium, ALWAYS differs from the mental image. The only escape is to imagine things at the level of I CAN accomplish–which feels like cheating.

    My mind and my hands speak a different language? Or we imagine things without limitation but make things in a restricted range? Or just my brain making up things it doesn’t have to actually do?

  2. Nancy Whiteon 10 Sep 2015 at 5:37 am

    Scott, YES YES YES. There is something about integration there too. Thank you!

  3. Scott Johnsonon 10 Sep 2015 at 8:39 am

    Nancy, the idea of integration of self is a popular goal in a lot of self-help and spiritual books I read. But the unpredictable nature of having different “me’s” inside is cool too. It develops a sense of self-tolerance to contain different skill sets that disappoint the ambitions of Mr / Mrs Perfect who think they are running the show.

    “Objects are not triggers for internal events in the nervous system; they are opportunities or affordances for our continuing transactions with them.” Left on autopilot, my brain runs a continuous film clip of me battling the powers that are attempting to diminish me. This forces a single response that runs concurrently. Fortunately, being an un-integrated whole, there’s always some little difficulty wandering around in there just looking to break the abysmal continuity.

Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 United States
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 United States.
%d bloggers like this: